| # Player | Wins |
| 1. Stephanie Petrycki, 2002 | 84 |
| 2. Mary Wilson, 2010 | 66 |
| 3. Liz Axler, 2005 | 65 |
| 4. Danielle Rautenberg, 2004 | 64 |
| 5. Cristin Arahovites, 2003 | 63 |
| 6. Adrienne Markison, 2011 | 61 |
| 7. Gabby Pasternak, 2007 | 60 |
| Kim Piazza, 2004 | 60 |
| Katherine Ehle, 2005 | 60 |
| Amanda Petruzzi, 2007 | 60 |
| 11. Danielle Rodriguez, 2007 | 47 |
| 12. Sarah Viebrock, 2012 | 46 |
| 13. Jackie Herb, 2008 | 44 |
| 14. Rachel Cantor, 2012 | 39 |
| Tina Hoany, 2006 | 39 |
| 16. Heather Rahm, 2003 | 35 |